Audio Research CD5 CD Player
by Paul Bolin | October 1, 2009
I am by nature something of a Luddite, especially when it comes to audio equipment. There are always the adventurous sorts who are the early adopters of a new medium or technology, but I prefer to wait things out. I still recall with some vividness the first CD player I ever owned, an early Sony. It was not terribly expensive, a second-generation player that I bought from the Harvard Coop. What I remember most about it is that I never made it through a full CD on the thing without a splitting headache.
Over the years, digital playback has improved to a degree I wouldnt have thought possible back in those early days of the medium. But apart from a pair of horribly costly but marvelous-sounding mbl separates I reviewed for The Abso!ute Sound nearly a decade ago, I have always preferred the simplicity and unfussiness of a single-box player. To be brutally frank, I am simply not technologically savvy enough to deal with something like the latest stack of dCS upsampler, resampler, transport, separate clock and all the accompanying wiring and interfaces. While I love the idea of a music server, having to load it with so many recordings and connect it to my audio system makes me break out in a cold sweat and start looking for a vodka martini. I like things to be as simple as possible, but no simpler.
All of which brings me to the quite-wonderful Audio Research CD5 CD player. It is a no-nonsense, straightforward piece of gear, handsomely styled, as solid as a brick and as intuitive to use as an axe or a baseball bat. It is also a top-loader, which appeals to my essentially analog sensibilities. Physically putting a disc into a player, securing the beautifully machined (and individually balanced) magnetic clamp and sliding the CD5s substantial door closed may be more complicated than using a drawer mechanism, but it is more viscerally satisfying to my sometimes-curmudgeonly mindset.
Audio Research Corporation (ARC) should be no stranger to anyone reading this, and is certainly no stranger to digital playback. While ARC entered the source-component field later than most, it was immediately apparent that they had done their homework and worked out the kinks that bedeviled so many early adopters. The latest iteration of ARC's solid-state CD player is the CD5; Marc Mickelson is currently enjoying ARCs Reference CD8, with its tubed output stage. I hope we can swap players at some point, as the difference between the two units are solely the CD8s tubed output stage and the power-supply differences mandated by glowing glass. Apart from these distinctions, the two players are identical. Both use the same brawny Philips PRO2M CD drive mounted on an equally hefty suspended subchassis, the same 24-bit chipset (the source of and tweaks to which Audio Research will not disclose), the same fully balanced circuitry, and the same dependably excellent build quality one expects from this high-end stalwart.
Audio Researchs chief listener Warren Gehl rang me up to offer the player for review and delivered it in person a couple of weekends later. I must mention for the sake of completeness that ARC went to the trouble of putting about 400 hours on my sample unit to save me the time of breaking it in. Warren explained that the CD5 (and most electronics) need a certain amount of break-in time for the signal paths to burn in and the capacitors to finally form. Given fifteen years of grim tedium breaking in gear for review, I knew he was speaking the truth, and I was able to get down to evaluative listening right off the bat. Let it be said that the CD5's character didnt change in the slightest in the two-plus months I listened to it. Also worth mentioning is that ARC is one of the few audio companies to embrace a green attitude in designing its products. The CD5 is meant to be left on and in standby at all times, but it consumes a miniscule 14 watts in standby and only 20 watts in operation.
One of the first discs onto the CD5's mechanism was Philip Glasss Akhnaten [CBS 42457], a longtime musical favorite that has always managed to sound somewhat opaque and undifferentiated, albeit musically breathtaking, no matter what I played it on. With the CD5, the opaqueness I had always attributed to this being an early digital recording was largely stripped away. Glass orchestrated the opera without violins, and the cellos and basses take on a bigger melodic burden than with many orchestral pieces. A sense of clarity that had always been lacking suddenly materialized, with the string sections individualized very nicely and the lucid rhythmic drive -- always vitally important to Glasss music -- much more to the fore. The woodwind choirs embroideries were no longer obfuscated by a muzzy translucence but presented with a bracing clarity. As for the singers, the massed vocals of "The Family" were sumptuous and cleanly defined. Paul Esswoods potent countertenor in the title role and the baritone recitatives of David Warrilow were more natural and less chesty and congested than I had been used to hearing, and to much more natural effect.
Another favorite CD of mine is Shine [Starworld/BMG PD-6621] by the now-defunct Korean girl group Sugar. It combines a fizzy, engaging pop sensibility with catchy tunes, a wide variety of techno/dance influences and exceedingly slick production. That the girls can all sing convincing lead and lovely harmonies is the cherry atop the sundae. Yes, I am well aware that this is not exactly Audiophile Approved source material. So revoke my Audio Snobs Union card. Ive loved girl-group pop since I first heard the Ronettes on AM radio when I was a mere sprout and this is nothing more or less than a 21st-century Asian riff on the same tradition. Besides, it always puts a big, stupid smile on my face when I listen to it.
Oddly, Shine is one of those rare recordings that sounds better and better as ones system improves. Ive heard it dozens if not hundreds of times, and twice on systems anchored by the CD5, where it has suddenly opened up into a broad and deep soundstage with the girls (admittedly rather over-compressed) voices floating rather deliciously over the cinematic techno-pop backgrounds.
Shine also has some brutally demanding synthesizer bass transients that no acoustic instrument will ever be able to manage. "Natural" instruments have gradual attacks in the deepest bass. With stringed instruments there is the process of plucking or bowing, which takes a small but noticeable time between the beginning and end of the plucking or bowing motion; with pipe organs there is the quick but clearly audible delay of the pipe beginning to speak prior to the full impact of the note. An electronic keyboard can go from nothing to a powerful fundamental tone instantaneously. In terms of transients alone, there is no more demanding test for any component in an audio system. The CD5 handled torture tests like Shines "Lets Feel the Music" and Future Sound of Londons "Papua New Guinea" from The Papua New Guinea Translations [Jumpin and Pumpin CD TOT52] with outstanding pitch definition and control. The Wilson Audio Sasha W/P would certainly have let me know if anything had been missing from the CD5s bass depth, articulation and control, and nothing was. This ability to play depth-charge fundamentals did not translate to any bloat or overripeness with pianos, cellos or double basses. Timbral bloom and precision were never sacrificed on the altar of sheer power through the ARC.
The CD5s midrange was consistently excellent. It never shortchanged harmonic completeness, and this was most notable on vocals. Eva Cassidys Live at Blues Alley [Blix Street G2-10046] is an exemplary live recording, apart from the obviously artificial reverb on the singers voice. The CD5 points out the artificiality of that reverb but without untoward emphasis and, more importantly, without compromising Cassidys rich voice. The acoustic guitar, charmingly sung harmonies, and yearning melody of Sugars "Just For My Love" had just the right blend of sweetness and bracing clarity. Fritz Reiner and the CSOs definitive recording of Richard Strausss Also Sprach Zarathustra [RCA Living Stereo 61494-2] showcased a naturally balanced string sound with a near-ideal blend of woody instrument bodies and a naturally shimmering top.
The presentation of the top octaves is where Red Book digital has traditionally, and justifiably, been open to criticism for harshness and graininess. The CD5 showed finesse and refinement on every good recording. Subjectively, the players top showed no grain or grittiness anywhere, only an appealing combination of detail and oneness with the rest of the audible spectrum.
The CD5s dynamic performance was consistently exceptional. The ARCs ability to resolve detail in a convincing musical context stood out on Live At Blues Alley, where Cassidy showed a thorough command of dynamic nuance. The subtleties of her phrasing and dynamic shading had a convincing and flowing presence through the CD5, which tracked her voice beautifully. Dynamics had a natural liquidity with no "ratcheting," only a natural billow or swell as provided by the music. Treble dynamics, which I dont think get talked about enough, were unusually lifelike. There was no exaggerated hotness on crescendos, no dulling of the top end during quiet passages.
Soundstaging was essentially a reflection of what was on each disc, with nothing added or subtracted. The shallow but very broad stage in Chicagos Symphony Hall sounded just as it should with Zarathustra, and the CD5 caught what is most often heard on top-notch LPs -- the violins and violas, which are held horizontally under the chin, bloomed up expansively towards the microphones. Artificial soundspaces were truly capacious when appropriate. The cosmic expansiveness of "Clouds Again" and "Tri-Cycle Gliss" from Gongs Live 25th Birthday Party [Voiceprint/GAS 101CD] was spot on, and so was the massively reverbed Duane Eddy-style "twangy" guitar sound created for Julee Cruise by David Lynch and Angelo Badalamenti on Floating Into the Nights "Floating" and "Falling" [Warner Bros. 9 25859-2]. Most impressive was the length of the decay; the guitar hung in a huge cushion of air and slooowly diminished to a precisely defined point, always trailing away and never just winking out into the blackness of digital zeroes. Imaging was pleasingly precise without artificial highlighting or compartmentalizing of each voice or instrument into a neat little hermetically sealed box that stands outside the context of the whole.
The CD5 is nearly dead neutral timbrally, though I did notice at times a slight, and I do mean slight, leanness or coolness in the upper midrange and lower treble with both the EgglestonWorks Andra II and the Wilson Audio Sasha W/P. This characteristic doesnt define the player, and it cannot be described as a failing; perhaps it is more a lack of a coloration common in other digital players that romanticize this range. (This is the primary reason I would like to hear its fraternal twin, the Reference CD 8, for purposes of comparison. The tube output stage of the Reference player would provide an interesting contrast, given the players otherwise identical design.) The CD5 is remarkably evenhanded across the tonal spectrum and has clarity of line and presentational plainspokenness that are habit-forming. The CD5 is so well balanced in all aspects of its performance that allowances do not need to be made for it. This is one CD player that will not provide a sonic makeover for mediocre recordings. Its nature is to be unflinchingly honest. This extends to the essence of performances and not just sound. Sviatoslav Richters mesmerizing performance of the Schumann Piano Concerto [Deutsche Grammophon "Originals" 447-440-2] is no less riveting for its rather blah sonics.
Unless you have a system composed entirely of lean, chilly-sounding components, I find it basically impossible not to recommend the CD5 with the highest degree of enthusiasm. It does nothing less than excellently with any kind of music one might wish to hear and brings with it Audio Researchs 40-year history of standing staunchly behind every component it has ever made and well-deserved reputation for reliability and general excellence.
IPods? Phooey! Computers as a part of my audio system? Bunk! Simple is as simple does, and the CD5 provides simple excellence in every way that is musically meaningful. Nuff said for now, though a follow-up will be coming once I hear my temporarily sidelined reference Lamm M1.2 amplifiers with the Wilson Sasha W/Ps.
Warranty: Two years parts and labor.
Audio Research Corporation
3900 Annapolis Lane North
Plymouth, Minnesota 55447
Analog front-end: SOTA Cosmos Series III turntable, Graham 2.2 tonearm, Dynavector XV-1s phono cartridge, Hovland Music Groove phono cable, Aesthetix Io Signature phono stage.
Preamplifier: Aesthetix Calypso line stage.
Power amplifier: Classé Audio CAM-350 monoblocks.
Loudspeakers: EgglestonWorks Andra II, Wilson Audio Specialties Sasha W/P.
Interconnects: Acoustic Zen Silver Reference 2, Cardas Golden Reference, Nordost Valhalla.
Speaker cables: Cardas Golden Reference bi-wire (EgglestonWorks Andra IIs), Shunyata Antares (Wilson Sasha W/Ps).
Power conditioners: Shunyata Research Hydra Model-8 (front end) and Shunyata Research Hydra Model-2 (power amps).
Power cords: Shunyata Research Anaconda Alpha, Anaconda Helix Alpha and Anaconda Helix Vx; Nordost Valhalla.